April 15, 2026 (Clinton Jaws) - CNN Host Speechless as Guest Fact Checks Her lies Live On TV!
Republican Elise Stefanik Gets Into a Heated Argument With CNN Over Trump - This Is Priceless For free and unbiased Medicare help, dial 513-642-9742 to speak with my trusted partner, Chapter, or go to https://askchapter.org/jaws Footage Courtesy of CNN #trump #usa Chapter and its affiliates are not connected with ...
April 15, 2026 (Opinion) - APRIL FOOLS: Two weeks of immigration & judicial failures
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 15, 2026 (Opinion) - 500K TO LEAVE CANADA? Punishing citizens for leaving, shows signs of a failing nation- Gunter
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 15, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - He's An Independent Man 🤫😉
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 15, 2026 (Jamie Schmale) - Are Your Property Rights Safe?
Canadians already face enough pressure from high costs and economic uncertainty, yet now they’re being left to wonder if their home is truly theirs. The Cowichan ruling has created real doubt about property rights, and the Liberals failed to defend them in court. Conservatives are calling on ...
April 15, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - Canadians choose INVASION over Carney until 2029..
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 15, 2026 (The Ben Mulroney Show) - Meet the Conservative MP Ben calls an "assassin" in the House of Commons
On today's episode of "The Ben Mulroney Show," Ben welcomes current Member of Parliament for Newmarket-Aurora, Sandra Cobena. In this conversation, Cobena, a former banker, shares her journey from finance to politics - "the Canada that my kids are growing up in is actually ...
April 15, 2026 (The LeDrew Three Minute Interview) - Robin Bredin: Canada Is Being DESTROYED by Its Own Government
Is Canada’s government growing beyond control? In this explosive preview of a longer conversation, Stephen LeDrew sits down with Robin Bredin — described as a “public provocateur” — to tackle a blunt and controversial idea: that government in Canada is no longer serving its citizens, but ...
April 15, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - Why Haven't They Moved 🤣
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 14, 2026 (Opinion) - LILLEY UNLEASHED: Has the Liberal majority weakened Poilievre’s leadership?
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 14, 2026 (Opinion) - LIBERAL GAME PLAN: Don't fix a thing, just hold onto power- Gunter
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 14, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - He Got Caught Lying 😭
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 14, 2026 (Opinion) - LILLEY UNLEASHED: International forces impacting Canada’s food supply and prices
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 14, 2026 (Jamie Schmale) - The $90 Billion High-Speed Disaster
Canadians already face enough pressure from high costs and economic uncertainty, yet now they’re being left to wonder if their home is truly theirs. The Cowichan ruling has created real doubt about property rights, and the Liberals failed to defend them in court. Conservatives are calling on ...
April 14, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - Canada is about to find out..
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 14, 2026 (The Post Millennial) - Parents Defending Education: The Fight Against Wokeness In America's Classrooms
In this episode of The Pod Millennial, the host Libby Emmons sits down with Nicole Neily of Defending Education, to discuss how ideological content has infiltrated K-12 schools at every level and how COVID's remote learning unexpectedly exposed parents to what was (and wasn't) being ...
April 14, 2026 (The LeDrew Three Minute Interview) - Carney’s China Deal EXPOSED? Canada’s Arctic at Risk
Is Canada’s government growing beyond control? In this explosive preview of a longer conversation, Stephen LeDrew sits down with Robin Bredin — described as a “public provocateur” — to tackle a blunt and controversial idea: that government in Canada is no longer serving its citizens, but ...
April 14, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - He Destroyed Him 😭
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 14, 2026 (Clinton Jaws) - 'The View' Host Sunny Hostin Breaks Down Crying Over Trump - This Is Priceless!
Republican Elise Stefanik Gets Into a Heated Argument With CNN Over Trump - This Is Priceless For free and unbiased Medicare help, dial 513-642-9742 to speak with my trusted partner, Chapter, or go to https://askchapter.org/jaws Footage Courtesy of CNN #trump #usa Chapter and its affiliates are not connected with ...
April 13, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - He Obliterated Her 😭
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 13, 2026 (The Ben Mulroney Show) - When will Canadians say "enough is enough" when it comes to floor-crossing?
On today's episode of "The Ben Mulroney Show," Ben welcomes current Member of Parliament for Newmarket-Aurora, Sandra Cobena. In this conversation, Cobena, a former banker, shares her journey from finance to politics - "the Canada that my kids are growing up in is actually ...
April 13, 2026 (The Ben Mulroney Show) - Trudeau goes to Coachella with Katy Perry after telling Canadians not to travel to the US
On today's episode of "The Ben Mulroney Show," Ben welcomes current Member of Parliament for Newmarket-Aurora, Sandra Cobena. In this conversation, Cobena, a former banker, shares her journey from finance to politics - "the Canada that my kids are growing up in is actually ...
April 13, 2026 (Opinion) - LILLEY UNLEASHED: Carney uses fear of Trump not to fix Canada but to grab more power
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 13, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - Carney's plan to prevent Canadians from leaving
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 13, 2026 (The LeDrew Three Minute Interview) - Carney Let China Buy Canada’s Critical Mining Companies! Smart Move?
Is Canada’s government growing beyond control? In this explosive preview of a longer conversation, Stephen LeDrew sits down with Robin Bredin — described as a “public provocateur” — to tackle a blunt and controversial idea: that government in Canada is no longer serving its citizens, but ...
April 13, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - Their Beliefs Aren't Compatible 🤯
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 12, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - They're Not Pulling Their Weight 🤐
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 12, 2026 (Aaron Gunn) - Liberal Minister Must Tell Canadians the Truth!
Wow. This is the most surreal exchange I’ve ever had in Canada’s Parliament. It’s obvious the Liberals are desperately trying to cover up what their blind allegiance to the UN’s 30x30 agenda actually means. Instead of refusing to answer questions, the Liberal Minister needs to stop deflecting ...
April 12, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - Bill Maher SHUT DOWN Mass Immigration
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 11, 2026 (Clinton Jaws) - Bill Maher vs The Moon - This Is Priceless!
Republican Elise Stefanik Gets Into a Heated Argument With CNN Over Trump - This Is Priceless For free and unbiased Medicare help, dial 513-642-9742 to speak with my trusted partner, Chapter, or go to https://askchapter.org/jaws Footage Courtesy of CNN #trump #usa Chapter and its affiliates are not connected with ...
April 11, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - This Judge STOOD His Ground 💪🏼💪🏼
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 11, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - When Canada FAILS, What will YOU do??...
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 11, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - They've Gone Too Far 😭🤯
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 10, 2026 (Clyde Do Something) - President Trump TROLLED Mark Cuban 😭
Credit: @TheFallenStateTV Have a Cup of Coffee with Me - Best Canadian Roasted Coffee available at Clyde Brew Something Coffee clydedosomething.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Thinking about moving to the USA? Talk to my friends at The Bridge: https://move2theusa.com/ -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Protect your wealth with Gold and Silver - The Cost of Living is Going ...
April 10, 2026 (Opinion) - BATRA’S BURNING QUESTIONS: For Israel the Iran war is about more than oil
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 10, 2026 (The Ben Mulroney Show) - Conservative MP admits she didn't have Marilyn Gladu floor crossing "on her bingo card"
On today's episode of "The Ben Mulroney Show," Ben welcomes current Member of Parliament for Newmarket-Aurora, Sandra Cobena. In this conversation, Cobena, a former banker, shares her journey from finance to politics - "the Canada that my kids are growing up in is actually ...
April 10, 2026 (The LeDrew Three Minute Interview) - LeDrew Rant - Iran, Trump, and Canada — The Truth No One Wants to Say
Is Canada’s government growing beyond control? In this explosive preview of a longer conversation, Stephen LeDrew sits down with Robin Bredin — described as a “public provocateur” — to tackle a blunt and controversial idea: that government in Canada is no longer serving its citizens, but ...
April 9, 2026 (The Ben Mulroney Show) - A case for why the government shouldn't regulate alcohol
On today's episode of "The Ben Mulroney Show," Ben welcomes current Member of Parliament for Newmarket-Aurora, Sandra Cobena. In this conversation, Cobena, a former banker, shares her journey from finance to politics - "the Canada that my kids are growing up in is actually ...
April 9, 2026 (Jamie Schmale) - WATCH: Conservatives Demand Action to Protect Property Rights
Canadians already face enough pressure from high costs and economic uncertainty, yet now they’re being left to wonder if their home is truly theirs. The Cowichan ruling has created real doubt about property rights, and the Liberals failed to defend them in court. Conservatives are calling on ...
April 9, 2026 (Opinion) - BATRA'S BURNING QUESTIONS: Carney gets another floor crosser; is Poilievre's party blowing up?
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 9, 2026 (Opinion) - LILLEY UNLEASHED (EXCERPT): Should Supreme Court or Parliament have the final word on the law?
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 9, 2026 (The LeDrew Three Minute Interview) - Dan McTeague: Gladu’s Betrayal Will Cost – A LOT
Is Canada’s government growing beyond control? In this explosive preview of a longer conversation, Stephen LeDrew sits down with Robin Bredin — described as a “public provocateur” — to tackle a blunt and controversial idea: that government in Canada is no longer serving its citizens, but ...
April 8, 2026 (The Ben Mulroney Show) - Another one bites the dust...floor crossers are taking over Parliament
On today's episode of "The Ben Mulroney Show," Ben welcomes current Member of Parliament for Newmarket-Aurora, Sandra Cobena. In this conversation, Cobena, a former banker, shares her journey from finance to politics - "the Canada that my kids are growing up in is actually ...
April 8, 2026 (The Ben Mulroney Show) - The Carney King Syndrome: What's Driving the Hype?
On today's episode of "The Ben Mulroney Show," Ben welcomes current Member of Parliament for Newmarket-Aurora, Sandra Cobena. In this conversation, Cobena, a former banker, shares her journey from finance to politics - "the Canada that my kids are growing up in is actually ...
April 8, 2026 (The Ben Mulroney Show) - Another one crosses the floor and what it means for the Liberals
On today's episode of "The Ben Mulroney Show," Ben welcomes current Member of Parliament for Newmarket-Aurora, Sandra Cobena. In this conversation, Cobena, a former banker, shares her journey from finance to politics - "the Canada that my kids are growing up in is actually ...
April 8, 2026 (Opinion) - ALL HEAT AND NO MEAT: Trump’s tariffs have hit Americans harder
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 8, 2026 (Opinion) - LILLEY UNLEASHED: Crying in your beer got more expensive on April 1
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
April 8, 2026 (The LeDrew Three Minute Interview) - Why Do So Many Canadians Believe The Lies? | Jerry Amernic on Cancel Culture
Is Canada’s government growing beyond control? In this explosive preview of a longer conversation, Stephen LeDrew sits down with Robin Bredin — described as a “public provocateur” — to tackle a blunt and controversial idea: that government in Canada is no longer serving its citizens, but ...
April 7, 2026 (The Ben Mulroney Show) - Chris Hadfield on Artemis II and the colonization of space
On today's episode of "The Ben Mulroney Show," Ben welcomes current Member of Parliament for Newmarket-Aurora, Sandra Cobena. In this conversation, Cobena, a former banker, shares her journey from finance to politics - "the Canada that my kids are growing up in is actually ...
April 7, 2026 (Opinion) - A FIREARMS FARCE: Liberal gun ban firing blanks
“We have the system under control”, so said Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada's iron-clad immigration system. Of course, the headlines tell a very different story about the junk justice state of affairs. Even one respected Ontario judge described the system as "feckless" when it comes ...
CNA Live
Al Jazeera Live
WION Live
GB News Live
TRT World Live
Say something about this; Add a comment...
Recent Comments...
See what others have said on YouTube...
Favorite
Save to your favorites...
(0🗩)
14+
Anonymous Badger-1530 Deport
Anonymous Salamander-6125 So time to send them back
Anonymous Toad-7100 Major job losses in Canada , who cares. Ha ha ha this guy is a fucking moron
Anonymous Raccoon-1873 He's lining his pockets with our money. I'm sick of this country of no consequences. I work my bag off for these pieces of corrupt shits to steal from us. Jesus h Christ
Anonymous Mink-8620 What a loser!
Anonymous Red panda-5459 When Europeans arrived, the natives hadn't managed to create woven cloth, or a written language, or even invented the wheel. The used their women and children as pack animals, raided other camps for hostages and torture victims, used leaves and bits of fur to wipe their backsides, and barely managed to feed themselves. Now, they live in government-supplied homes, enjoy free education, free health care, and pay little or no taxes. Oh, and they can use toilet paper now. They were never the grace-filled 'keepers of the land'. They were Stone Age hunter-gatherers.
Anonymous Magpie-2354 I was confused at first why Trump pushed for Carney. Trump would have had to fight and get mutual deals with Poilievre as both men are their own country first. Carney hasn't lived here for decades. We don't matter to him, his investments and profit does. He overtly rewards his generals more pay then himself, he's a fake. Carney is trying to sell you they're a new party. He's lying to your face, as Trudeau's top ministers stand behind him and Carney was advising Trudeau for years. Either too many Canadians don't understand English, are on welfare, unionized, are federal workers, or insane to vote Liberals in again. The West has a chance to prosper if they split 🪓, Canada will fall, believe it!
Anonymous Rail-2485 Carney, the snake oil salesman who earned his way up the ladder riding other people's coattails. Total scam
Anonymous Koala-9701 SHIT SHOW!!!
Anonymous Armadillo-7090 There's something very dirty and unethical going on here. Greed, keeping people sick for big pharma? What they are doing stirs all this, and creates massive trust issues.
Anonymous Pelican-2718 Absolute losers! They all backed that asshole Singh who kept our country hostage for years and now they're sorry! As Canadians suffered. Fuck you! They don't even deserve 7 seats!! And the west needs to get out of this dumpster fire and seperate! Unbelievable EASTERN Canadians voted for more destruction! Get us out of this hell!!!
Anonymous Spoonbill-4944 This is so sad. But we can waste funds on other countries for gender, trans, feminism, climate or pooping on the beach!
Anonymous Cassowary-7205 Nobody listened. Canada can burn
Anonymous Finch-7540 Boomers with trump derangement voted for this lol. WEXIT
Anonymous Buffalo-5095 It's been closed since Christmas holidays 2024, they got a raise during that time too. Half of Canada are the dumbest people. That's enough Canada needs to be divided in half.
Anonymous Yak-4014 If the Liberals are elected again, I foresee a seismic shift, not just with those already planning to move to Alberta like us. Canada could lose the west entirely. Either some provinces will split or if they don't, Trump could easily destabilize us by offering youth visas, and opportunities for our business'. Quite frankly, if Canada is so stupid to reelect the Liberals, I hope the govt report that Canada is going to collapse in 15 years happens! So the USA can take over and clean the communist rot that has taken a deranged foot hold here. You can thank the govt funded media for helping to expedite Canada's demise. Like Chinas hold on media, they brainwash, spread propaganda and unfortunately there are too many easily manipulated losers in Canada, COVID proved that. If Pierre is elected, we will all flourish without government media! Trust me, I come from a communist shit hole. Media is their NUMBER ONE weapon.
Anonymous Wombat-1069 This guy is PPC
Anonymous Emu-5538 Why the love for Communism? My family escaped that torture, why the west want it so bad?
Anonymous Llama-287
@FullMoonFever58 said: You've lost your mind. Canada is already lost and NOT because of Trump. Look what the man is doing for Americans. If Carney wins, we're f*cked and we need Trump more than you know! Who's stopping the fentanyl, who's allowing PRC police stations on Canadian soil, who allowed all these unvetted migrants into Canada, who's disarming Canadians, who has given millions to Hamas, Who is allowing "Death To Canada" and the burning of our flags??? I could go on and on, but no it's all Trumps fault??? WAKE UP CANADA!
Well said. Liberal voters are like mindless comrades, it's a lost decade, and they want to forget what they've done the last 10 years, because, orange man bad, The news tells me to think this way. Elbows up, pushed by a guy that lives in the states, in memory to another guy that spent most of his life in the USA, playing hockey for the USA. The irony.
Swati Joshi From start to finish, your content is simply amazing. You have a talent for making complex topics easy to understand and I always come away with valuable insights.
FYI! there's 24/hour news on the last row
Choose a section below to browse while you watch
🎉 Welcome!
📰 More News
📝 Share a story
🎙️ Podcasts
🗞️ Media Bias Chart
Loading....
(fetching the latest content)
More News
Share a story
Podcasts
Media Bias Chart
Conservative motion to scrap fuel taxes VOTED DOWN by other parties